Saving Your Super Bowl Bacon: How One Advertiser Performance Tested Early and Avoided Disaster

SuperBowl2014__140201231903During Super Bowl  XLVII, Coca Cola, Axe, Sodastream, Calvin Klein had their hands full. Not so much serving online visitors as running around looking for quick fixes for their crashed websites. As reported by Yottaa.com, no fewer than 13 of the companies that ran ads during that Super Bowl saw their websites crash just as they needed them the most.

If anything in this world is ever going to be predictable, a large spike in traffic when you show your ad to a Super Bowl audience must be one of those things.

Thats why one leading digital agency – ROKKAN –  worked with us to guarantee the stability of their client’s campaign website just days ahead of their Super Bowl XLVIII TV commercial.

Getting this level of performance assurance not only eased their client’s concerns, it also showed how committed ROKKAN was to the quality of execution.

As with any advertising campaign, its not only about the glitz and glamour of the ad, its about the ability to motivate action on the part of the audience. And if that motivation is to visit a website, you better be damn well sure that website can take the heat and deliver an exceptional experience. Anything less translates to lost customers, degraded reputation and fewer sign ups – as was this advertiser’s campaign objective.

Background:

The auto industry was the biggest sponsor of the Super Bowl for the third straight year this year. No fewer than seven brands advertised during Fox TV’s telecast of the National Football League’s championship game on Sunday, February 2, 2014.

On average, the carmakers spend as much as $6 million per 30-second spot, for the chance to get in front of an estimated 100+ million viewers. 

“When these types of investments are made, if your website doesn’t work, it becomes very ugly, very quickly for all parties involved in the campaign,” said Jim Blackwelder, chief technical officer for ROKKAN, a Publicis Groupe company that’s done award winning work for American Express, jetBlue, Chipotle, Ceasars Palace, and TAG Heuer. “Everybody just expects technology to work these days, and if it doesn’t, everyone notices.”

Test setup:

The Super Bowl Sunday challenge for ROKKAN – a 2014 Advertising Age A-List Agency for the third consecutive year – could not have been clearer: the target user load for its automaker client’s microsite promoting the features of an upcoming luxury sedan, was over 250,000 visitors per hour coming in from across the country and around the world.  But initial performance tests of the website using Load Impact failed far short of that goal.

“That first test was a total eye-opener,” said Blackwelder.  “Load Impact showed us we had a lot of work to do to get performance where it needed to be.”

At the advice of Load Impact, ROKKAN split performance testing to separately hit the website run by the hosting company Rackspace. The tests were done by going through and around the Rackspace content delivery network (CDN) to uncover crucial performance and configuration issues with both scenarios.

Daily meetings and testing ensued. 

Challenges:

“The team at Load Impact realized that without a full court press – a really integrated effort with all of the stakeholders including ROKKAN, their service providers, as well as Load Impact – the success of the project was far from guaranteed,” said Charles Stewart, Load Impact’s general manager for U.S. operations. 

Solution:

With less than one week from kickoff, ROKKAN made changes and optimizations to problems identified by Load Impact at the caching layer, application layer and hardware layer, that brought page load times to under 4 seconds with just over 10,000 simultaneous users.  

It was 20 times better than when they started, but still a long way from their goal. As an added complication, eleventh hour changes requested by the automaker adversely impacted performance dramatically.

Load Impact and the ROKKAN team examined the data and identified network bandwidth as the likely cause of the performance degradation, and produced reports to support the findings.

With data in hand, Blackwelder was able to go to Rackspace’s network team, which quickly identified and resolved the remaining bottlenecks, increased throughput to the site, and gave ROKKAN’s platform the capacity it needed to scale.  

Results:

The automaker’s website was ready for game day.

“Had we not done performance testing we never would have uncovered a range of issues with both our work and our partners,” said Blackwelder. “Without Load Impact our hitting the project goals and schedule would have been at risk. But it wasn’t at all.  It was a huge success.”

The automaker’s site performed perfectly under the Super Bowl traffic, far exceeding expected connections per second without breaking a sweat, and delivered the customer sign-up conversions that were the automaker’s key success metric.

“For many of ROKKAN’s projects we thought of performance testing as a nice-to-have. But for this project and any of its type, it’s an absolute need-to-have. We needed large scale capacity testing, real-time viewing, and robust reporting, with a platform that could respond to change quickly, and Load Impact delivered on all counts.” – Jim Blackwelder. 

———–

This is a perfect example of how NOT to waste $4 million (not including production costs). If you’ve got a big marketing campaign coming up, make sure your audience can actually fulfill the action you want them to take – performance test your campaign website/app early. 

Countdown of the Seven Most Memorable Website Crashes of 2013

Let this be a lesson to all of us in 2014. 

Just like every other year, 2013 had its fair share of website crashes. While there are many reasons why a website might fail, the most likely issue is the site’s inability to handle incoming traffic (i.e. load).

Let’s look at some of the most memorable website crashes of 2013 that were caused by traffic overload.

#7. My Bloody Valentine

imgres-3February 2nd, obviously not so alternative shoegaze legends, My Bloody Valentine, decided to release their first album since 1991, and they decided to do so online. They crashed within 30 minutes.

In the end, most of their fans likely got hold of the new album within a day or two and the band, which clearly has a loyal fanbase, probably didn’t end up loosing any sales due to the crash.

#6. Mercedes F1 Team 

Lewis_Hamilton_2013_Malaysia_FP2_2Mercedes F1 team came up with a fairly clever plan to promote their web content. In february, they told fans on Twitter that the faster they retweeted a certain message, the faster the team would reveal sneak preview images of their 2013 Formula One race car.

It worked a little too well. While waiting for the magic number of retweets to happen, F1 fans all over the world kept accessing the Mercedes F1 web page in hopes of being the first to see the new car. Naturally, they brought the website down.

You guys are LITERALLY killing our website!” Mercedes F1 said via Twitter.

#5. NatWest / Royal Bank of Scotland

rbs-nat-west-1-522x293Mercedes F1 and My Bloody Valentine likely benefited from the PR created by their respective crashes, but there was certainly nothing positive to come out of the NatWest/RBS bank website crash. A crash which left customers without access to their money!

In December, NatWest/RBS saw the second website crash in a week when a DDOS attack took them down.

It’s not the first DDOS attack aimed at a bank and it’s probably not the last one either.

#4. Sachin Tendulkar crash

imagesOne of Indias most popular Cricketers, Sachin Tendulkar, also known as the “God of Cricket”, retired in 2013 with a bang! He did so by crashing local ticketing site, kyazoonga.com.

When tickets for his farewell game at Wankhede in Mumbai became available, kyazoonga.com saw a record breaking 19.7 million hits in the first hour, after which the website was promptly brought down.

Fans were screaming in rage on Twitter and hashtag #KyaZoonga made it to the top of the Twitter trending list.

#3. UN Women – White Ribbon campaign 

images-1

It may be unfair to say that this website crash could have been avoided, but it’s definitely memorable.

On November 25th – the International Day for the Elimination of Violence against Women – Google wanted to acknowledge the occasion by linking to the UN Women website from the search giant’s own front page.

As a result, the website started to see a lot more traffic than they’ve been designed for and started to load slowly, even crashing entirely.

Google had given the webmasters at unwomen.org a heads up and the webmasters did take action to beef up their capacity, but it was just too difficult to estimate how much traffic they would actually get.

In the end, the do-no-evil web giant and unwomen.org worked together and managed through the day, partly by redirecting the link to other UN Websites.

Jaya Jiwatram, the web officer for UN Women, called it a win. And frankly, that’s all that really matters when it comes to raising awareness for important matters.

#2. The 13 victims of Super Bowl  XLVII

Super_Bowl_XLVII_logoCoca Cola, Axe, Sodastream, Calvin Klein had their hands full during Super Bowl XLVII. Not so much serving online visitors as running around looking for quick fixes for their crashed websites.

As reported by Yottaa.com, no fewer than 13 of the companies that ran ads during Super Bowl saw their websites crash just as they needed them the most.

If anything in this world is ever going to be predictable, a large spike of traffic when you show your ad to a Super Bowl audience must be one those things.

#1. healthcare.gov

imgres-5The winner of this countdown shouldn’t come as a surprise to anyone. Healthcare.gov came crashing down before it was even launched.

It did recover quite nicely in the last weeks of 2013 and is now actually serving customers. If not exactly as intended, at least well enough for a total of 2 million americans to enroll.

But without hesitation, the technical and political debacle surrounding healthcare.gov makes it the most talked about and memorable website crash in 2013.

Our friends over at PointClick did a great summary of the Healthcare.gov crash. Download their ebook for the full recap: The Six Critical Mistakes Made with Healthcare.gov

There’s really nothing new or surprising about the website crashes of 2013. Websites have been developed this way for years – often with the same results. But there are now new methodologies and tools changing all that.

It isn’t like it used to be; performance testing isn’t hard, time consuming or expensive anymore. One just needs to recognize that load testing is something that needs to be done early and continuously throughout the development process. It’s not optional anymore. Unfortunately, it seems these sites found that out the hard way. A few of which will likely learn the lesson again in 2014.

Our prediction for 2014 is more of the same. However, mainstream adoption of developmental methodologies such as Continuous Integration and Delivery, which advocate for early and continuous performance testing, are quickly gaining speed.

A Google search trend report for the term, DevOps, clearly shows the trend. If the search trends are any indication of the importance being given to proactive performance testing by major brands, app makers and SaaS companies, we might only see half the number of super bowl advertiser site crashes in 2014 as we did last year.

DevOps Trend

Update following Superbowl XLVIII: According to GeekBeat, the Maserati website crashed after their ad featured their new Maserati Ghibli. And monitoring firm, OMREX, found two of the advertiser websites had uptime performance issues during the game – Coca-Cola and Dannon Oikos.

About Load Impact

Load Impact is the leading cloud-based load testing software trusted by over 123,000 website, mobile app and API developers worldwide.

Companies like JWT, NASDAQ, The European Space Agency and ServiceNow have used Load Impact to detect, predict, and analyze performance problems.
 
Load Impact requires no download or installation, is completely free to try, and users can start a test with just one click.
 
Test your website, app or API at loadimpact.com

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.